济溪环保公益

 找回密码
 立即注册

微信登录

微信扫一扫,快速登录

搜索
查看: 3307|回复: 4

日益繁荣的中俄能源贸易引发了环境抗议和反对在东西伯利亚建设新水电站的法律诉讼

[复制链接]
发表于 2012-11-27 23:35:20 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
中俄能源贸易的环境隐忧
珍妮•约翰逊
27.11.2012
日益繁荣的中俄能源贸易引发了环境抗议和反对在东西伯利亚建设新水电站的法律诉讼。




main_boguchanskaya_hydropower_plant.jpg

报道称,博古尚斯卡娅大坝的建设会导致近1000万立方米的森林被淹没。 图片来源:Сайга20К


东西伯利亚地区与中国接壤,边界线长达四千公里。这里经济落后、人烟稀少,但却可以为它发展迅速、人烟稠密的邻国——中国提供丰富的资源,其中水电至关重要。

10月31日,中俄达成了在东西伯利亚新建一座大型水电站的协议。由于中俄企业正在俄罗斯东部谋求互惠互利的合作开发,这一地区的许多地方可能都会签署这样的协议。

俄罗斯计划新增1000万千瓦的发电能力,其中大部分是水力发电。在一个能源合作框架下,这些来自数千公里外、隔着数个时区的西伯利亚的电力将被用来供应华北的最大负荷。如果中国用不完,还可以供应给当地方兴未艾的工业,如木材、矿产、金属、煤炭、石油和其他资源的开发,而这些资源中有很多也是供应给中国市场的。

“当千百万北京人早上起床后打开电水壶准备沏茶的时候,他们用的电可能来自西伯利亚的水电站,西伯利亚的大坝。问题在于,我们要为北京人泰然自若地打开电水壶付出什么样的代价?我们的代价就是西伯利亚的河流。” 克拉斯诺亚尔斯克环保团体“对大坝说‘不’””的负责人亚历山大·克罗托夫说。

中俄能源贸易热潮

2012年将是中俄能源贸易史上标志性的一年。俄罗斯政府估计,截至今年底,俄罗斯向中国出口的能源数量将比2011年增加一倍以上,即从去年的12亿千瓦时增加到26亿千瓦时。

这个高潮似乎还将继续下去,因为俄罗斯政府承诺要为新的大型能源项目提供资金。俄总统普京在11月22日签署了一道总统令,将从本年度的联邦预算中划拨出500亿卢布(16亿美元)给俄罗斯水力发电公司(RusHydro),支持其在俄远东进行新电力供应计划的建设。根据总统令的说法,这个行动旨在对一些大型项目进行资助,以便增强对外界投资者的吸引力。

对于购买俄罗斯电力,中国也提出了初步的长远计划。2011年,中国国内用电总量猛增11%,中国政府开始着手与俄罗斯电力供应商合作。今年2月,中国国家电网公司与俄罗斯东部能源公司(俄政府的国际电力供应商InterRAO的下属企业)签署了一项合同,未来25年中将为中国提供1000亿千瓦时的电力。

在上述协议签署之前,俄罗斯的联邦电网公司已经完成了一条新的500千瓦输电线路的建设。根据俄联邦电网公司的说法,这条线路名为阿穆尔—黑河线,将成为连接克拉斯诺亚尔斯克地区与中国边境的主线。

俄罗斯最大的私营能源企业——俄罗斯能源集团有限公司(EuroSibEnergo)也力图在上述合同电力的供应中扮演主角。该公司是EN+集团旗下的企业,后者与俄罗斯铝业公司一样,都是俄商业寡头奥列格·德里帕斯卡的产业。目前EuroSibEnergo在西伯利亚已经有四座水电站,而且还准备与中国伙伴一起扩大发电规模。

2011年,EuroSibEnergo与中国长电国际有限公司(长电国际)合作建立了一家名为YES Energo的合资企业,长电国际是中国长江电力股份有限公司的子公司,而长江电力则属于中国长江三峡集团公司。

YES Energo的任务是建成1000万千瓦的新发电能力,主体是东西伯利亚和远东的水力发电。已经宣布的目标有两个:一个是发展俄罗斯欠发达东部地区的经济,另一个是向中国出口电力。

输送到中国的水电

最近在拉斯诺亚尔斯克地区立项的博古尚斯卡娅水力发电厂是EuroSibEnergo公司的旗舰项目。它的建设是由2006年与RusHydro达成的公私合作伙伴关系负责的,后者是俄罗斯政府全国水力发电建设的经营者。

2013年博古尚斯卡娅水电厂全面投入运转后,总发电量能力将达到300万千瓦。其中大部分电力已经被俄罗斯铝业公司预定,它目前正在建设一座新的大型电解铝厂。多余电力将进入西伯利亚总电网,其中一部分可能会输往到中国。

这座水力发电厂既是一个典范,也是一个警告,说明为了向中国提供电力,未来可能会上马很多大规模的发电项目。这些项目包括提议中的石勒喀河上的跨西伯利亚水电大坝和安加拉河上的下安加尔斯基大坝。

“对大坝说‘不’”的克罗托夫说,为了建设博古尚斯卡娅大坝,最近大约有1000万立方米的森林被淹没,而且水位还在不断上涨。克罗托夫等人如今正在起诉EuroSibEnergo 和RusHydro,控告他们在没有进行环境控制、没有保护被淹没地区文化遗产情况下就开始修建大坝。

俄罗斯总检查官办公室11月12日表示,该水库的蓄水违背了法律要求,可能给当地生态带来威胁。据记者说,水库没有将树木和生活垃圾、岩屑等废弃物清理干净就开始蓄水,结果将形成一座不断腐烂的死海,而且还会给河流带来疾病和无法挽回的伤害。

RusHydro 则回应说,水库底部的清理工作是由当地政府负责的。

许多之前住在被淹没地区的居民说,他们在移民安置过程中深感受骗,一些人力图为家园的丧失寻求更高的补偿。根据记者和居民的说法,许多具有历史意义的遗迹都被淹没了,坟墓只有一部分被迁移。11月初,政府只是下令将一些已经淹没在水库中的考古遗址地从官方政府登记簿中删除。

最大受益者:俄罗斯还是中国?

随着博古尚斯卡娅水电站带来的损害得到了评估,克罗托夫准备为未来的建设项目进行更多的斗争。他说:“我们有巨大的力量,在这儿还没有用出来。我们这里的电站将一个接一个地建,建这些电站只是为了出口能源,对本地区一点用都没有。”

克罗托夫也对本地能否从能源出口业务中获益表示怀疑。

他说:“中国想用很便宜的价格买到电力,不能超过中国国内的电价 。结果,我们要努力刺激的是中国的经济,而非我们自己的。我们把电便宜卖给中国,然后中国再生产出便宜商品卖给我们。这样一来,中国就赚了两次。”

博古尚斯卡娅水力发电厂将建在一座新的大型工业园区内,相关企业表示,这个工业园区耗资50亿美元,将是世界上最大的在建能源和金属项目,也是25年来俄罗斯最大的投资项目。新的博古尚斯基电解铝厂的产量将达到每年60万吨,2013年投入经营后有望成为地方经济发展的火车头。

随着中俄经济合作的不断拓展,未来类似的发展方案及其骇人的环境后果将在欠发达的俄罗斯东部各地一次又一次地出现。



翻译:奇芳
每个人都关心自然环境,理解、参与环境保护,与自然和谐相处,分享改变世界,爱济溪
 楼主| 发表于 2012-11-27 23:35:52 | 显示全部楼层
The underdeveloped, sparsely populated Eastern Siberia region that shares a 4,000-kilometre border with China has vast resources to offer its heavily populated and fast-developing neighbour. Hydroelectricity is key among them.

A major new hydroelectric plant commissioned on October 31 stands as an example of what may transpire in many places throughout eastern Russia, as Russian and Chinese companies look to exploit the region for mutual benefit.

Russia plans up to 10,000 megawatts of new capacity, mostly hydroelectric, to supply China with energy under a scheme where peak loads in northern China will be powered by Siberian hydropower thousands of kilometres and many time zones away. When the electricity isn’t needed in China, it can power emerging regional industries in the exploitation of timber, minerals, metals, coal, oil and other resources, much of which is also destined for the Chinese market.

“When millions of people in Beijing wake up in the morning and turn on their electric boilers for tea, that electricity will be coming from Siberian hydroelectric stations, Siberian dams,” says Alexander Kolotov, director of the environmental group No to Dams in the eastern city of Krasnoyarsk. “The thing is, what price are we paying so that Beijing can calmly click on their electric boilers? We will pay for that with our Siberian rivers.”

Russia-China energy trade boom

The year 2012 may mark a turning point for the energy trade between Russia and China. The Russian government estimates that, by the end of the year, Russia will have exported more than double the amount of electricity to China than in 2011 – over 2.6 billion kilowatt hours, up from 1.2 billion kilowatt hours last year.

The surge is likely to continue, as the Russian government is showing its commitment to financing major new energy projects. Russian president Vladimir Putin signed an executive order on November 22 that allocates 50 billion rubles (US$1.6 billion) from this year’s federal budget to RusHydro’s plans to construct new electricity supply in the Russian Far East. The move is aimed at initially funding some major projects so that they become more attractive to outside investors, according to the announcement.

China has also put forward initial long-term commitments to purchase Russian power. After China's domestic electricity demand jumped 11% in 2011, the Chinese government got on board with Russian providers. In February, the State Grid Corporation of China signed a contract with the Eastern Energy Company, an arm of the Russian government’s international electricity supplier InterRAO, which will see 100 billion kilowatt hours of electricity supplied to China over the coming 25 years.

The contract came after Russia’s Federal Grid completed construction of a new 500-kilovolt transmission line, called the Amurskaya-Heihe, which will become the main line from the Krasnoyarsk region to the Chinese border, according to Federal Grid documents.

EuroSibEnergo, Russia’s largest private energy company, is looking to be a major player in supplying the contracted electricity. It is a subsidiary of EN+ Group, a company operated by oligarch Oleg Deripaska that also controls aluminum producer RUSAL. EuroSibEnergo already controls four hydropower plants in Siberia, and it is looking to expand those holdings with Chinese partners.

EuroSibEnergo established a joint venture called YES Energo in 2011 with China Yangtze International, a subsidiary of China Yangtze Power, which is controlled by China Three Gorges Corporation.

The YES Energo venture is designed to build up to 10,000 megawatts of new capacity, the bulk of it in hydropower, in Eastern Siberia and the Russian Far East. The stated goals are both to develop the economy of Russia’s underdeveloped eastern region and to export electricity to China.

Hydropower sent to China

The recently commissioned Boguchanskaya hydroelectric plant in Krasnoyarsk territory is EuroSibEnergo’s flagship project. It was constructed under a public-private partnership formed in 2006 with RusHydro, the Russian government’s operator of hydropower installations nationwide.

Boguchanskaya will generate 3,000 megawatts of electricity when it is fully operational in 2013. Most of that has been promised to RUSAL, which is currently constructing a major new aluminum smelter. The excess electricity will go to the general Siberian grid, where some of the power will likely be sent to China.

The plant serves as an example – perhaps a warning – of what may be in store under future projects built expressly for the supply of electricity to China. These include the proposed Trans-Siberian hydroelectric dam on the river Shilka and the Nizhny-Angarskii hydroelectric dam, also on the Angara River.

About 10 million cubic metres of forest have recently been flooded for the Boguchanskaya dam, and the water level is still rising, according to Kolotov of campaign group No to Dams. Kolotov and others are now suing EuroSibEnergo and RusHydro for constructing the dam without environmental controls or measures to save cultural heritage lost in the flooded area.

The Russian General Prosecutor’s office said on November 12 that the filling of the reservoir violated legal requirements and potentially threatens the ecology of the region. The reservoir was not cleared of trees and other debris before being filled, and the result is a rotting, dead sea, which threatens to spread disease and irreparably harm the river, according to reports.

RusHydro said in response that the local government was responsible for clearing the reservoir bed.

Many residents who previously lived in the flooded area say they feel cheated by the resettlement process, and some are seeking greater compensation for the loss of their homes. Many sites of historical significance were flooded, as well as cemeteries that were only partially relocated, according to the reports of residents. In early November, the government ordered dozens of archaeological heritage sites, which are now located under the reservoir, to be taken off the official government register.

Who benefits most – Russia or China?

As the damage from the commissioning of the Boguchanskaya plant is being assessed, Kolotov is preparing for more fights on future projects. “We have a huge amount of energy, and we don’t use it here,” Kolotov said. “Here we will have another station built and then yet another. . . and these stations are utterly useless for the region. They are being built only for the export of energy.”

Kolotov also doubts the region will benefit from the energy export business.

“China wants to buy electricity very cheaply, at a price not higher than the internal price in China. As a consequence, we are going to stimulate the development of the Chinese economy and not our own. We are going to sell cheap electricity to China, China will produce cheap goods, sell them to us, and we will buy them. So it turns out China wins twice,” Kolotov said.

The Boguchanskaya hydropower plant is part of a new US$5 billion industrial complex that the companies involved say is the world’s largest energy and metal project under construction and the largest investment project in Russia for 25 years. The new Boguchansky aluminum smelter will have the capacity to produce 600,000 tonnes per year and is expected to become a locomotive of development in the region when it begins operation in 2013.

Similar development scenarios, along with their striking environmental consequences, may play out again and again across undeveloped eastern Russia in the coming years as Russia and China expand their economic cooperation.
每个人都关心自然环境,理解、参与环境保护,与自然和谐相处,分享改变世界,爱济溪
发表于 2012-11-27 23:45:53 | 显示全部楼层
这标题也是够长的
国内的水电还没折腾完又跑去邻邦了……

49

主题

4580

回帖

1万

积分

印度洋

积分
19830

社区居民最爱沙发

发表于 2012-11-28 00:05:37 | 显示全部楼层
俄罗斯国家能源战略
1、制订能源纲要,提高俄罗斯油气在国际能源市场上的比重。
2、国家恢复对能源部门的控制,仅国家控股的俄罗斯石油公司和俄天然气工业公司就垄断了本国1/3石油和95%天然气的生产,控制了几乎全部的天然气管线。
3、不仅要用油气资源,还要通过管网来谋求地缘经济利益。国家控制的石油天然气公司要打入西欧和独联体国家的天然气分配和石油销售系统。早在2005年俄天然气工业公司就同中亚国家签订协议,买断全部天然气运输能力到2010年,买断土……天然气25年。
4、对外能源合作的原则是在长期合同基础上并通过能源资本的相互融合来保证供求双方能源安全。
5、能源出口多元化,既面向欧洲,也面向亚洲。为本国长远利益计,在亚洲方向,油管直通大庆不如通到太平洋之滨的纳霍德卡,虽然造价高3倍以上,但买主将由一家变为中、日、韩、美等多家。
6、用能源和原材料产业提升“创新经济”,发展高科技,以便今后俄经济不依赖或少依赖能源产业,用部分出口收入解决经济和社会问题,俄白能源之争迟早会停,但……借助能源来实现本国战略目标的方针不会变,能源外交为国家安全和经济利益服务的理念也不会变。
家庭  4/0  金玉其外败絮其中 快乐的生活  0.01/0  没感觉的 找个人陪着  0/0  没必要祸害他人 感情  0/0  年轻就该冷漠,年轻就该残忍(更是对自己) 活的阳光一些  0/0  你笑一个不阴暗的给我看 身体  N/A  身体是用来虐的,此生难得 相信我的人  ?/A  呵呵,不要相信我,对彼此都好 还属于地球人的GSEANer除了我愿望都会实现的

49

主题

4580

回帖

1万

积分

印度洋

积分
19830

社区居民最爱沙发

发表于 2012-11-28 00:10:24 | 显示全部楼层
“当千百万北京人早上起床后打开电水壶准备沏茶的时候,他们用的电可能来自西伯利亚的水电站,西伯利亚的大坝。问题在于,我们要为北京人泰然自若地打开电水壶付出什么样的代价?我们的代价就是西伯利亚的河流。” 克拉斯诺亚尔斯克环保团体“对大坝说‘不’””的负责人亚历山大·克罗托夫说。

水电作为可再生、无污染的环保型能源,可能会引发的环境问题有:
1、河道脱减水
2、植被遭破坏,水土流失加剧
3、移民安置的环境影响
4、改变流域河道生态系统

自然,还涉及国家安全、经济及独立自主与支配权问题的
家庭  4/0  金玉其外败絮其中 快乐的生活  0.01/0  没感觉的 找个人陪着  0/0  没必要祸害他人 感情  0/0  年轻就该冷漠,年轻就该残忍(更是对自己) 活的阳光一些  0/0  你笑一个不阴暗的给我看 身体  N/A  身体是用来虐的,此生难得 相信我的人  ?/A  呵呵,不要相信我,对彼此都好 还属于地球人的GSEANer除了我愿望都会实现的
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册 微信登录

本版积分规则

小黑屋|手机版|济溪 ( 京ICP备17053947号-1 )

GMT+8, 2024-11-23 07:58 , Processed in 0.035696 second(s), 29 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

© 2001-2023 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表